Two sides to the same equation
The UAW loss of their union representation election at Volkswagen made national headlines a couple of weeks ago. While these kind of elections are always contentious, and can cause serious disruption within an organization, the Chattanooga election outcome has elicited criticism from organized labor about the “unprecedented” involvement of outside parties. The employees at Volkswagen even went so far as to create their own non-profit worker center named Southern Momentum as part of their effort to keep the UAW out of their facility. This is a very new thing in labor relations, and something we may see more of in the future. Lawyers for both sides are already busy filing arguments about the validity of such worker groups before the NLRB. Lawyers for Southern Momentum say these charges are an effort by the UAW to silence them because their efforts were effective during the recent election.
The Battle for Hearts and Minds
What seems to be lost in this dialogue is that it was really the votes of 712 VW employees who decided the outcome of the election. A simple majority made their vices heard in a secret ballot election and said “No thanks” to the UAW. There are similar efforts going on at the plants of other auto manufacturing plants in the Southern United States. These efforts are largely being driven around the idea that the UAW is working to create a new kind of labor union representation model in the United States, based on cooperation between the parties and a democratic approach to worker involvement in the plants by a Worker Council. This is a traditional European model that is difficult to create under existing US labor law. There are always two sides in a fight over union representation, those who support the union; and those who are against it. Every union election is a battle for the hearts and minds of the undecided and the uncommitted, and the rhetoric you hear usually reflects that. Here is what the campaign rhetoric looks like in the ongoing campaign at the Mercedes plant in Vance Alabama:
Welcome to UAW-MBUSI Organizing!
- We know the UAW is not here to help us, they are here to help themselves to a portion of our paychecks after they helped bankrupt the Detroit auto industry and helped themselves to a taxpayer bailout
Where do you stand on unions?